How to Choose the Best Collar for Your Dog: A Trainer’s Guide

When it comes to training your dog, the right collar can make a world of difference. A well-fitted collar keeps your pup safe, comfortable, and focused during walks and training sessions. But with so many options out there, how do you know which one is best for your dog?

At Dogo, we work with thousands of pet parents and trainers every day, so we know that no single collar works for every pup. The best choice depends on your dog’s behavior, training level, and lifestyle. To make your decision easier, we’ve put together this guide to help you choose the perfect collar – and we’ve highlighted a few trusted options from Mimi Green, known for their high-quality, handmade dog gear.

For Everyday Wear: Flat Buckle Collars

Best for: Well-trained pups, casual walks, and holding ID tags.

Flat buckle collars are the go-to choice for most dogs. They’re lightweight, comfortable, and great for everyday wear. If your dog doesn’t pull on the leash, this style is ideal. For stylish, durable options, Mimi Green offers personalized flat collars made from laminated cotton, leather, and waterproof Biothane.

Dogo Training Tip:
Even if your pup wears a flat collar daily, we recommend pairing it with a harness during leash training to avoid putting pressure on the neck.

For Escape Artists: Martingale Collars

Best for: Dogs who slip out of traditional collars or need more gentle leash control.

Martingale collars are a trainer’s favorite because they gently tighten when your dog pulls, giving you more control without choking. They’re beneficial for breeds with narrower heads, like greyhounds or whippets, but work for any dog who tends to back out of collars.

Check out Mimi Green’s martingale collars for beautiful, secure, and customizable options.

Dogo Training Tip:
Use a martingale collar during leash training to provide gentle, consistent feedback while keeping your pup safe and secure.

For Adventurous Pups: Waterproof & Outdoor Collars

Best for: Dogs who swim, hike, or love muddy adventures.

If your dog loves the outdoors, a waterproof collar is a game-changer. Mimi Green’s Biothane collars are durable, odor-proof, and easy to clean – perfect for training sessions on the trail or by the lake.

Dogo Training Tip:
Choose lightweight, quick-dry gear for outdoor training so your dog stays comfortable and focused no matter the weather.

For Better Control: Harnesses for Training

Best for: Puppies, pullers, and dogs working on leash manners.

Sometimes, collars aren’t enough – especially for dogs learning polite leash walking skills. A good harness distributes pressure across the chest instead of the neck, making it safer and more comfortable. Mimi Green’s step-in harnesses are trainer-approved, adjustable, and designed to match their collars and leashes for a complete set.

Dogo Training Tip:
Pair a harness with positive reinforcement training to encourage good leash habits without causing discomfort or stress.

Make It Personal

A dog’s collar isn’t just functional—it’s part of their identity. Personalized engraved buckles or nameplates ensure your pup’s information is always easy to find. We recommend checking out Mimi Green’s personalized collars for high-quality, customizable designs.

When choosing a collar, focus on safety, comfort, and training goals. The right gear supports your dog’s learning and makes every walk more enjoyable.